Hubbell Gardiner in The Way We Were (1973)
Let's be honest, the chemistry between Robert Redford and Barbra Streisand is amazing, and it's on full display in this classic romantic drama. Redford plays Hubbell Gardiner, the seemingly perfect, all-American writer who falls for the fiery, politically active Katie Morosky. What makes this role so memorable is Redford’s subtle portrayal of a man caught between his easy-going nature and the passionate, complicated world his partner inhabits.
He’s charming, but Redford also shows the cracks in Hubbell’s golden facade, revealing a man who ultimately chooses comfort over conviction. It’s a heartbreaking performance that captures the bittersweet reality of love and ideals clashing, making Hubbell a beautifully flawed character.
Roy Hobbs in The Natural (1984)
In what might be the ultimate feel-good baseball movie, Robert Redford embodies the mythic figure of Roy Hobbs. After a promising career is cut short, Hobbs returns to the game as a middle-aged rookie with a mysterious past and a near-magical talent for hitting. Redford brings a quiet, world-weary dignity to the role, perfectly balancing the character's boyish love for the game with the pain of his lost years.
You can feel the weight of his regrets and the burning desire for one last shot at greatness. When he finally steps up to the plate for that legendary, light-shattering home run, it’s pure cinematic magic, made entirely believable by Redford’s performance.
Jeremiah Johnson in Jeremiah Johnson (1972)
As the titular mountain man, Robert Redford delivers a gritty, physical performance that is largely silent, relying on presence and action over dialogue. He plays a disillusioned veteran who escapes civilization to live off the unforgiving land of the Rocky Mountains. The film follows his journey from a novice survivalist to a hardened, legendary figure.
Redford masterfully conveys Johnson’s transformation through his interactions with nature and the few people he encounters. It’s a rugged, soulful performance that strips away the Hollywood glamour to reveal a powerful actor at his peak, crafting a compelling narrative of survival, loss, and the untamed American spirit.
Bob Woodward in All the President’s Men (1976)
Playing one half of the reporting duo that took down a presidency is no small task, but Redford's portrayal of Bob Woodward is a remarkable example of subtle yet powerful performance. Alongside Dustin Hoffman's Carl Bernstein, Redford captures the relentless drive of a journalist chasing the biggest story of his life.
He plays Woodward with a cool, methodical focus, showing the gears turning as he pieces together the Watergate scandal. What makes this role so memorable is how Redford makes the painstaking work of journalism. There's a lot of phone calls, note-taking, and late-night meetings in parking garages. He embodies the quiet heroism of seeking the truth, making this not just a great performance but a vital piece of cinematic and political history.
The Sundance Kid in Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid (1969)
This is it. The role that made Robert Redford a superstar and defined his on-screen persona for decades. As the quick-drawing, thoughtful outlaw opposite Paul Newman’s charismatic Butch Cassidy, Redford is pure movie magic. His Sundance is the quieter half of the duo. He was a man of few words but lightning-fast reflexes.
The legendary chemistry between Redford and Newman created one of cinema’s greatest pairings, full of witty banter and genuine camaraderie. Redford’s performance is the perfect blend of cool confidence and underlying vulnerability, creating a character who is both a Western hero and a deeply human man facing the end of an era. It’s the role he was born to play, and it remains his most iconic and unforgettable contribution to film.
Author
Shannon Sanford
Last Updated: September 16, 2025